One of the most
important choices you have to make when joining a defined contribution
scheme (i.e. an occupational money purchase scheme, a personal pension plan or a
stakeholder pension scheme)
is how your money will be invested.
These types of scheme are provided by various approved bodies
such as insurance companies, banks, building societies and
investment companies. The all offer a choice of different types of
fund in which to invest your payments. Your choice of provider may
be influenced by the type of fund, or funds, in which you decide to
invest. Another determining factor is the risk involved.
Risk
Risk is a measure of uncertainty. Those saving for their
retirement, whether through a pension scheme or otherwise, face a
range of uncertainties and need to have some understanding of these
if they are to manage the risks involved. We will try to outline
some of these under the following headlines which are not
comprehensive:
Inadequacy Risk
Irrespective of the other risks involved, the greatest risk any
saver faces is that their investments will be inadequate for the
purposes for which they are saving. In the case of a pension
scheme, this means that it does not produce sufficient income to
provide you with the standard of living you wanted to achieve.
The elements which can give rise to this are;
- the contributions made to your scheme have not been
enough,
- the return on your investments has been poorer than you had
been hoping,
- inflation had been greater than anticipated leaving you in a
situation where the purchasing power of your pension is less than
you had expected,
- the annuity rates prevailing at your retirement provide less
pension than you need.
Some( possibly all) of these elements are outside your control,
e.g., future inflation, but others you may have some, albeit
limited, ability to influence. It is you who decide how much you
save. You should review regularly whether you are saving enough to
meet your needs in retirement. Similarly you need to take an active
interest in the performance of your investments and be prepared to
make changes if the investment manager is not matching your
expectations, provided those expectations are realistic. Finally,
you may be able to influence the impact of annuity rates by being
prepared to be flexible with regard to when you take your
pension.
Investment Risk
Investment risk is the likelihood of your investment failing to
fulfill your expectation of the returns you hope to achieve. This
could be in terms of the income produced, the growth in capital
value or both. Risk and reward tend to go together: the greater the
risk, the higher should be the reward. However, this is not always
the case.
The period of the investment is a determining factor; the
shorter the period, the less likely that the greater returns will
manifest themselves, whereas the longer the period of investment,
the more likely that the higher returns will be realised. This
means that higher risk types of investment are most suitable for
those with a long period before the investment needs to be
realised. In pension scheme terms this would mean a term in excess
of 5 years although some commentators would advise that higher risk
investments should only be considered by those with at least 10
years to retirement.
Currency Risk
When you invest overseas, in addition to the investment risk,
you are also open to the additional risk that the foreign currency
reduces in value against the £. This means that the value of your
overseas investment also decreases when measured in terms of
£s.
Not only can the overseas stock market suffer volatility but so
also can the currency. Gains on the market may be reversed by falls
in the value of the currency. The ideal situation would be that
gains on the market are added to by an increase in the value of the
foreign currency as against the £.
To reduce the currency risk you can use funds that invest in a
range of overseas currencies and reducing the risk. Also some fund
managers take measures to remove or reduce the currency risk,
particularly at times when they believe the overseas currency is
likely to fall in value relative to the £.
Types of Fund
Most providers will have a wide selection of funds from which
you can choose. You do not have to put all of your money in one
fund but can spread it over a number of funds.
The following is a description of how these funds work and the
investment risks associated with them.
Q & A's
These are simple deposit accounts, resembling building society
and bank accounts, under which your money earns interest.
These funds are not generally suitable for long-term investment,
as the rate of interest granted is usually low. However, they would
be seen as low risk. They would normally be used in the following
circumstances:
- where you are approaching retirement and want to take your
money out of riskier investments in order to hold them in a low
risk fund until you actually retire. In this situation, you might
use a cash fund for up to a few years.
- where you believe the outlook for other investment markets,
e.g. equities, are uncertain and you want a safe but temporary
haven. In this situation, you may only intend to use a cash fund
for a few months but, if markets are falling, you could end up
using it for a few years.
- where you are exploring other investment options and haven't
yet decided the longer-term placement of your money, a cash fund
would be suitable for holding your savings for a short period.
- where you are moving money between funds but want to finesse
the timing, you could hold your savings in a cash fund until you
are ready to commit to a longer-term investment.
- where you are investing a large sum, e.g., a transfer from
another scheme, you may not want to commit it all in your chosen
fund at the same time but spread its placement over a period. In
that situation you could hold it in a cash fund initially and then
invest it gradually.
Bonds are issued by UK and overseas governments and companies.
Government bonds are usually referred to as gilts while those
issued by companies are known as corporate bonds.
A bond is a loan raised by the issuer who promises to pay out
interest at regular intervals, e.g. quarterly, and promises to
repay the loan at a specific time or within a specified period.
Bonds may be attractive to investors who want to generate
income. They can also be seen as low risk investments, particularly
UK government gilts, which are seen as carrying little or no risk
of not being repaid. Overseas government and corporate bonds may
carry a higher degree of risk of default and should provide a
higher return to compensate. Overseas bonds carry an additional
risk arising from the fact that your investment is specified in a
foreign currency, the currency risk.
There is an active market in bonds with investors buying and
selling them. As investment rates go down, so the cost of bonds
rise and as interest rates rise, so the cost of bonds
decreases.
Equity funds invest in the ownership of companies. Companies
issue shares in their business and these are sold on the stock
market. These shares are known as equities.
An equity fund will hold the shares of a variety of companies.
Equity funds have produced good returns over a period of years.
However, their short-term performance can be very erratic and a
significant fall in value can be experienced. For most investors,
equities are seen as a long-term investment.
The main risks associated with equities are that the value of
the share may fall, ultimately to zero if the company goes into
liquidation. By holding a wide range of different shares, an equity
fund will reduce this risk.
The main risk for a pension investor is that the values of the
shares in the fund have dropped at the point in time when you want
to retire and draw a pension from your pension savings.
There are a very wide variety of equity funds available for
pension investment. The more common types are:
- Tracker Funds
They try to mirror the performance of either a whole market, e.g.
the entire UK equity market, or part of it, e.g. the top 100
shares.
The attraction of this type of fund is that the risk element is
reduced due to the wide spread of companies invested in. Also the
charges for this type of fund are usually lower.
The main disadvantage is that lower risk usually comes at a cost,
in the form of a lower return.
- Specialist Funds
There seems to be an endless variety of specialist funds e.g.
smaller company funds, large company funds, special situation
funds, growth funds, income funds etc, all trying to give added
value by concentrating on a particular area of the stock market or
particular type of share. These funds would be considered high
risk
- Overseas funds
These funds invest in the equity market of a specific country, e.g.
USA, Japan, etc or in a particular geographical area, e.g. Europe,
Pacific area etc. The nature of the funds could be the same as this
previously mentioned, Tracker or Specialist.
The tracker funds would work in the same way as the UK tracker
funds and are an attempt to reduce risk. However, overseas funds
have an additional risk that comparable UK funds do not. Because
the investment is specified in a foreign currency, there is also
the currency risk.
Property funds invest directly in commercial property, offices,
shop, factories and warehouses. The value of units increase with
the rents received from the lease of the properties and
periodically the fund managers arrange for the holdings to be
independently valued. To the extent that the valuations reveal an
increase in value, this will lead to an increase in the value of
the fund units.
Although property has provided good long-term returns, there are
times when property values decline. In that situation, if you have
need for your funds at such a point in time, you may it difficult
to disinvest from the property fund. Even if you are able to do so,
it may be at a considerable discount in the unit price.
Property also carries the risk that the particular investments
entered into do no prosper, or at least not to the extent of other
comparable investments. As with equity based funds, your investment
performance is very dependent on the skills of those managing the
specific investments within the fund.
Managed funds are made up of a mixture of different types of
investment such as equities, bonds and cash. Some managed funds
will also include property and/or overseas investments. Spreading
investment over a mixture of different types in this way, reduces
investment risk. The thinking behind this approach is that not all
types of investment will perform poorly at the same time. However,
the skill of the investment manager is even more important in this
kind of fund, as it is their ability to change the mixture from
time to time that which will add value.
These are funds that take away some of the decision making with
regard to what type of investment to use and when to change
investment approach.
The approach of most lifestyle funds is that the pension scheme
member should invest for growth when they are young and far off
retirement. This means investing, mainly or wholly, in equities. As
retirement draws near, investment is gradually switched away from
equities to fixed interest and cash.
Most lifestyle funds make the change from an aggressive
investment approach (normally equities) to a conservative approach
(fixed interest and cash) on a mechanistic manner rather than
according to prevailing market conditions. Thus the switch will
take place over a fixed period of time, e.g., the 5, 10 or 15 years
before the investors selected retirement age. This switch will
happen automatically, even if market conditions at that time are
unfavourable, unless the scheme member intervenes to prevent
this.
Care should also be exercised by those who adopt lifestyle funds
but then change the date at which they decide to retire - at the
new date of retirement, the fund may be in inappropriate types of
investment.
Insurance companies normally run this type of fund. The money in
the fund is usually invested in equities, bonds and cash. Investors
buy units in the fund. The capital value of the units doesn't fall
even though the value of the underlying investments may fall. To
allow this to happen, a reserve account is built up when investment
returns are good. The reserve account is drawn on in periods when
investment returns are poor. The value of a unit increases each
year subject to the performance of the underlying investments and
the ability of the manager to release part of the reserve account.
If the performance of the underlying investments is poor, there may
be years when the value of units does not grow.
This type of fund has been seen as low risk. However, the
performance of many of these funds in recent years has brought
about a new appraisal of their risk rating. This cannot be divorced
from the nature of the underlying investments and the size of the
reserve held. If reserves are low and the underlying investments
are high risk, e.g., equities, then the risk profile of the with
profits fund will also be high risk.
Another problem with these funds is the ability, written into
the documentation, for the fund manager to levy a charge should the
investor wish to encash their units at any time other than their
selected retirement age. This charge is called the Market Value
Adjustment and is intended to reflect the fall in value of the
underlying investments since the investor bought their units.
Many pension investors find it difficult to take an active
involvement in the investment of their own monies and so many
providers offer a default option into which pension contributions
are invested when the investor is unable or unwilling to make a
choice of their own. It is a requirement of all stakeholder schemes
to offer a default option but many personal pension plans do
not.
Some providers use their lifestyle fund, some use their managed
fund and others adopt a more conservative fund such as with-profits
or fixed interest.